Workers’ Comp Adjuster Tricks in Virginia and How to Handle Them

Nothing in this article should be taken as legal advice. Every case is different.

A workers’ comp adjuster works for your employer’s insurance company, and the adjuster’s job is to pay what the law requires and not a dollar more. The tactics that cost Virginia workers the most aren’t dramatic. They’re quiet: a recorded statement taken the first week, a medical release that opens your whole history, an agreement form with the wage figured low, or a body part left off the claim. Each one has an answer in Virginia law, and most of those answers have deadlines.

The Most Common Adjuster Tactics, and the Answer to Each

What the adjuster does What it can cost you The answer
Asks for a recorded statement right away Answers used later to deny the claim You can ask to schedule it for later. See recorded statements.
Sends a blanket medical release Your whole medical history, searched for pre-existing conditions You don’t have to sign it. Doctors treating the work injury must give reports on request (§ 65.2-604).
Says there’s no need to file because it’s paying A deadline you didn’t know was running File your own claim with the Commission (§ 65.2-601).
Figures your weekly wage low Every check smaller, for as long as you’re paid Check it against your pay for the 52 weeks before the injury (§ 65.2-101).
Accepts some body parts and not others No medical care or checks for what’s left off Read the agreement form line by line before you sign it, and check the award when it comes.
Sends you to its own doctor A report saying you can work, or that the injury isn’t from work One exam per specialty without Commission approval, and you can bring your own doctor (§ 65.2-607).
Pays late Bills you can’t cover, and pressure to settle After an award, a late payment can carry a 20 percent penalty (§ 65.2-524).
Makes an early settlement offer Your medical care closed for good, usually Every settlement needs the Commission’s approval (§ 65.2-701).

Those are a few of many. The sections below explain the ones that do the most damage.

“You Don’t Need to File, We’re Already Paying”

This is the tactic that costs workers the most, because the cost doesn’t show up until it’s too late to fix. In Virginia, your claim must be filed with the Workers’ Compensation Commission within two years of the accident (Va. Code § 65.2-601). Your employer’s report of the injury is not your claim.

Voluntary payments can pause that deadline in some situations (Va. Code § 65.2-602), but the rules are technical, the pause ends, and the insurance company decides when to stop paying. File your own claim even if the insurance company accepted your injury and is paying. There’s no fee to file a claim with the Commission. Here’s how to file a workers’ comp claim.

The Agreement Form With the Wrong Numbers

When the insurance company accepts a claim, it often sends an agreement form to sign. Once the Commission approves it, the numbers on it become your award. Check three things before you sign:

  1. Your average weekly wage. It should reflect your total earnings, including overtime pay, for the 52 weeks before the injury (Va. Code § 65.2-101). Overtime and extra shifts at that job are the parts most often left out. Here’s how workers’ comp is calculated in Virginia.
  2. The body parts. If you hurt your back and your knee, both should be listed. A body part that isn’t listed is one the insurance company can refuse to treat until the Commission orders it to.
  3. The dates. The weeks you’ve already missed should be covered.

The Commission has to approve the agreement before it becomes an award (Va. Code § 65.2-701).

The Insurance Company’s Doctor

The insurance company can send you to a doctor it chooses and pays, and if you refuse without good reason, your benefits can be suspended (Va. Code § 65.2-607). That same law gives you protections the adjuster won’t mention:

  • One exam per medical specialty. More than one requires the Commission’s approval.
  • Your own doctor can be there. You can bring a qualified physician, at your expense.
  • Reasonable times and places.

This is separate from the doctor who treats you. Here’s how to prepare for an IME in Virginia.

Surveillance and the Fraud Threat

Insurance companies sometimes hire investigators to film injured workers. The goal is a clip of you doing something that looks like it breaks your restrictions: carrying groceries, mowing, lifting a child. A short clip doesn’t show that you paid for it the next two days. It does get sent to your doctor with a question attached.

Some adjusters mention fraud to scare you into settling. Virginia’s fraud law is about knowingly making or using a written document with a materially false statement in a comp case. It applies to everyone involved, not just injured workers (Va. Code § 65.2-312). Telling your doctor the truth about what you can and can’t do, every time, is what protects you. So is staying within your restrictions in public and off social media.

Delays, Missed Calls, and Stopped Checks

Slow responses put pressure on you, and pressure makes a low offer look better. Two rules limit how far that goes:

  • Late payments. Once you have an award, a payment that comes due and isn’t paid within two weeks gets 20 percent added to it. The main exception is a delay outside the insurance company’s control, when it paid as fast as it could (Va. Code § 65.2-524).
  • Stopped checks. Under an award, the insurance company can’t simply stop paying. It has to file an application with the Commission, and you have 15 days from the filing date to respond (Commission Rule 1).

You can ask the Commission for a hearing no matter what the insurance company decides. Here’s what to do when the insurer delays your benefits.

The Early Settlement Offer

An early offer usually comes before anyone knows how the injury will turn out. Most full and final settlements close your medical benefits for good, so an offer made before surgery, a final rating, or a return-to-work decision prices those things without knowing them. Every Virginia comp settlement must be approved by the Commission, which has to find that it serves your interests (Va. Code § 65.2-701). That approval doesn’t mean the number is fair. Here’s what to know about lump sum settlements.

“The adjuster isn’t really your enemy, but they certainly aren’t your friend. The adjuster is doing a job, and that job is closing your file for as little as the law allows.” (Bryn Swartz)

What Not to Say to a Workers’ Comp Adjuster

Say less than you think you need to, and nothing you aren’t sure of. The lines that hurt claims most often:

  • “I’m fine” or “It’s not that bad.” It ends up in the claim notes and gets quoted later.
  • A guess. “I think it was around 2:00” becomes the time. If you don’t know, say so.
  • Your old injuries, in your own words. Prior back pain, an old car accident, or a sports injury will come up through records. Don’t describe them as related.
  • Blame. Who was at fault generally doesn’t matter in comp. Arguing about it only gives the adjuster more to write down.
  • Anything about other jobs, side work, or activities you haven’t talked through first. The law does require you to tell the insurance company right away about any new job or higher earnings. Do it in writing so there’s a record (Va. Code § 65.2-712).

Always tell the truth. The point is not to hide anything. It’s to keep a hurried phone call from becoming the official version of your injury.

Can You Scare an Insurance Adjuster?

No, and trying usually backfires. Threats and angry calls go into the claim notes. What actually moves a workers’ comp adjuster in Virginia is the Commission: a filed claim, a request for a hearing, a late-payment penalty, and medical records that answer the insurance company’s defenses. Adjusters handle many files. The ones with deadlines attached get attention first.

Adjuster Questions

Does the Adjuster Work for Me or for My Employer?

For the insurance company that covers your employer, or for a company hired to handle its claims. Either way, not for you.

Do I Have to Talk to the Adjuster at All?

You do have to go to properly scheduled medical exams, accept reasonable medical care, tell the insurance company right away if you go back to work or earn more, and answer formal questions once a claim is filed with the Commission. You don’t have to answer questions on the spot, sign every form sent to you, or give a recorded statement the moment you’re asked.

What if the Adjuster Offers Me a Light-Duty Job?

Read the job description against your doctor’s written restrictions before you answer. Refusing suitable light duty can stop your wage checks. Here’s more on light duty in Virginia.

Talk to Pathfinder Injury Law About Your Adjuster

Pathfinder Injury Law handles only Virginia workers’ compensation claims. Call 804-505-0633 or use our online contact form.

  • No Pressure

Free Consultation


Learn how we can help you with your Workers’ Comp case.

(804) 505-0633

Talk With Us

Step 1 of 8

Let’s start with your name

Call Us Message Us